Weekend Reading – Navigating the Retirement Risk Zone
Hey Folks!
Welcome to some new Weekend Reading about an important subject: navigating the retirement risk zone.
This is another important subject to understand if you are considering semi-retirement like I am or full-retirement at any age.
I’ll link to a few past posts and related considerations as part of this edition soon, first, a reminder: it’s “RRSP season”:
Weekend Reading – Navigating the Retirement Risk Zone
Readers, DIY investing advocates on this site, and equally importantly, prospective members to these low-cost retirement income services often wonder the following when it comes to retirement planning:
- What can I spend from my portfolio?
- How long could that money last?
- What accounts should I draw down first (to make my money last)?
I’ve asked those questions myself about our own portfolio – and I continue to do so!
Ultimately, there is no perfect answer since all inputs are subject to change: your account values, inflation, rates of return, taxation and variable spending just to name a few. This is why I’ve always said and firmly believe that retirement income planning is a process – one that has a beginning but it never really ends.
If your needs in semi-retirement or retirement are anything like mine, you want to accomplish a blend of the following:
- meet desired spending and fun,
- navigate and minimize taxation,
- fight some longevity risk.
In running my own math over the years my retirement income projections tell me a valuable story. While my retirement income budget has been established for a year or so now, something I will update later this year, it also tells me my own narrative about navigating the retirement risk zone.
What is the Retirement Risk Zone?
Simply put: the stakes are higher for you and me.
Years ago, I could afford a significant market loss and weather inflationary pressures since investing time was on my side when the market tanked and I could simply plow more money into the stock market – which I did. The same is not necessarily true in the years ahead. This is why I’ve been planning for a few years now – preparing for the 5-year period before semi-retirement begins and then positioning my portfolio for some downside protection after I start semi-retirement; for at least another 5-year period.

Image Source/Attribution to:
How to Navigate the Retirement Risk Zone?
While there are many tactics beyond this post, I think think some key ones to consider are the following:
- While it may be tempting to tap CPP and OAS income sources early in retirement – delaying each could be better. By optimizing your recurring, inflation-protected, pension-like retirement income streams like CPP and OAS at start dates of age 65 and beyond – you could be rewarded with hundreds of extra dollars per month!
- If you have an RRSP (R), non-registered account (N), and TFSA (T) entering semi-retirement or retirement, you might want to consider an RNT or NRT drawdown order. Related to RRSPs/RRIFs and LIRAs/LIFs, tapping these registered accounts sooner than later could not only help you with your retirement income needs in your 50s and 60s, you can also “smooth out taxation” from the tax-deferred assets inside this account. You can read about a free case study from Ashley and Tim to see this in practice below.
- You should consider how dependable your income streams are in semi-retirement or retirement if the stock market falls by 10%, 20% or more. (I’ll link to how long stock markets stay down later on in this post.) You might want to consider a cash wedge like Ashley and Tim have also done – they can ride out at least 1-year or so of really bad stock market returns without touching their RRSP portfolio at all.
The financial challenges to the Retirement Risk Zone are these key ones I’ve learned:
1. Market Risk – the years leading up to retirement are not the time for 100% high-risk investments. A stock market correction in this zone can really hurt your portfolio value. This is tied to some Sequence of Returns Risk. Beyond being all stocks all the time, this is why I also tend to ignore recent market returns when I do my own calculations/projections. Recent, higher portfolio returns of 20%+ for me including 2024 are not common. Instead, you may want to run some income planning reports that focus on more conservative returns along with modest to higher near-term inflation. (I use 5% returns and 3% inflation for my own income planning needs.)
2. Inflation Risk – ignore inflation at your peril. It’s one of the many wealth killers along with taxation and financial fees as shared by Larry Bates.
To help fight inflation over time, at least consider a bias to owning more stocks than bonds and within that, some equities that fight inflation too.
3. Longevity Risk – failing to see retirement income planning as an ongoing process, two things could happen: 1. you could run out of money too soon (which would be terrible of course) but 2. you could also leave lots of money on the table thanks to a lifetime of market anxiety and subsequently chronic underspending.
Summary: How to Navigate the Retirement Risk Zone
The most successful DIY retirees I know take all these key factors into retirement income planning consideration: market forces/drastic changes, inflationary pressures and potential longevity risk. This assessment work tends to occur long before retirement begins and long after retirement has started.
If you want to work through What-If scenarios in a low-cost way, I can help you whenever you wish including a discount just for being a My Own Advisor reader.
If you are working through your own spreadsheets and tools, all good too.
Aligned to my theme for this week, I see retirement as a continuous transition; the temperature and risks simply get turned up a few notches the closer you are to your retirement date and after. I look forward to sharing more details about how I embark on this transition during 2025.
More news to come in the coming months. Thanks for reading.
More Weekend Reading – Beyond Navigating the Retirement Risk Zone
Part of my inspiration for this week’s theme was from this post: $1 million is still a lot of money for any retirement.
From the author Nick Maggiulli:
“Whether we are looking at changes in prices or overall wealth, $1 million isn’t what it used to be. Today, you’d need anywhere from $2 million to $4 million to have the same buying power as millionaires around the turn of the century. But, focusing too much on the raw numbers misses a bigger point.
Because if I had to choose whether to be a millionaire in 1998 or today, I’d take today every time. The issue isn’t purchasing power, but the absolute level of goods and services that you can get today vs. 30 years ago. Though you could buy a better house back then with $1 million, just about everything else is better today.
We have better technology. We have better healthcare. We have better entertainment options. We have better shipping and logistics. And so forth. The device you are reading this blog post on is multiple orders of magnitude more advanced than anything that was available in the late 1990s.
When viewed from this perspective, $1 million goes further today than ever before.”
A Wealth of Common Sense blogger Ben Carlson wrote about the perfect level of wealth. From Ben:
“Unfortunately, many people never reach true contentment, no matter how much money they have.”
How long do stock market corrections last? It could be a year or more.
Finally, a reader asked me to link to this Globe and Mail article (subscription) that included some tax-timing tips:
- Check your brokerage or financial institution starting now for relevant tax slips; consider online delivery of these documents.
- A reminder of these key dates:
- Monday, Feb. 24: The Canada Revenue Agency’s Netfile service opens, which means tax returns can be filed online.
- Friday, Feb. 28: The final day for employers to issue T4s and T4As.
- Monday, March 3: The deadline to contribute to a registered retirement savings plan for the 2024 tax year.
- Wednesday, April 30: The tax filing deadline for most people. If you don’t meet the deadline, you could start incurring penalties if you owe money to CRA.
- Monday, June 16: The deadline for self-employed people to file their taxes. Any balance owing is due April 30.
Have a great weekend!
Mark
Hello Mark, I have used your DIY program last year and found it quite useful. I have also used a few free online retirement calculators. The one problem I have with this is that your income is spread out equally for every year. Slowly build up your cash to pay for a newish vehicle or home repair. Is it possible to design a product to add one time expenses that are withdrawn from a TFSA or non-reg. Now I am trying to decide if it is worth it to spend $4500.00 on a financial plan, and will it be any better? On your site and many others like it says to keep your fees low and to keep updating your plan. 4 or 5 years from retirement and a bit confused.
Thanks, Brian. Lots of free tools and lower-cost tools out there and all of them have a few pros and cons.
I believe any DIY spreadsheet, tools, commercial/professional software, etc. needs to have inflation factored in for sure.
Then, maybe to your point, you have a one-time expense and those tools also have the capability of inserting a one-time expense (newer car, new roof, etc.).
What I do, how I plan for this myself in a very simple way is I have part of my semi-retirement cashflow earmarked for future capital expenses; it’s simply part of upcoming planned spending and I have buffer too just in case things cost a bit more than I believe in a few years. An example:
-Our base expenses are $4k per month.
-I need $500 per month earmarked for a car in 10-years.
-Travel and discretionary spending is $1k per month.
-Buffer/contingencies, etc. is $500 per month.
__________
$6,000 per month spending in retirement. Which is our plan.
https://www.myownadvisor.ca/financial-independence-budget/
You might recall I also use 5% RoR and 3% inflation for our own projections and so if returns are better than 5% (they have been) and if inflation is different than 3% sustained, there is also some financial flexibility there too.
Since you have been a user of DIY, etc. tell you what, if you have a scenario you want me to post for you, let me know and I can consider it here. Happy to help you out a bit.
Paying $4,500 for a financial plan could be of some value but I think that depends on what you are looking for. I personally struggle with that much compensation to someone especially if you don’t need “advice” how to save, invest, etc. Seems a bit outrageous what some folks are charging.
I look forward to your reply.
Cheers,
Mark
Hi Mark,
I continue to enjoy your newsletters and wondered about Retirement Decummulation when you and I take into account our corporations. I’m guessing that starting with RRSPs, then the Corporation assets, then ? Non-Reg and lastly TFSAs? What are your plans? I was curious why in the 60K example they left the Non-Reg till last? Wouldn’t it be easier for the estate to deal with TFSAs?
Thanks again for the great info, cheers,
Alice
Thanks very much, Alice.
I consider the RRSP/RRIF and Corporation somewhat equal in that both are a tax liability – best to get rid of/draw down assets sooner than later.
Here is a good article and visual:
https://enrichedthinking.scotiawealthmanagement.com/2022/11/04/passive-income-taxation-for-canadian-controlled-private-corporations/
I am very likely to start paying myself a small dividend from my corporation starting in 2025 or 2026.
Based on my experiences in running various reports for clients including those that have corporations, the bias order (not always of course) is:
RRSP/RRIFs + Corporation (R), then Non-Reg., (N) then TFSAs (T) at the end.
There are times when it makes lots of sense to take down the non-reg. account first but those cases usually assume there is a very healthy non-reg. balance and that balance is > RRSP/RRIFs + any Corporation assets = rare for most.
Interestingly, most financial planning software I have encountered has a bias for NRT for the drawdown order but that’s usually because the software solutions do not like ongoing taxation – which can be tax-efficient for some and can be a override setting.
My approach is NRT in fact: live off dividends (N) from taxable account, make some strategic sales along the way; draw down RRSP/RRIFs + Corporation (R), then leave TFASs (T) until the end.
I keep that information updated on my Dividends page:
https://www.myownadvisor.ca/dividends/
I hope that helps! Let me know your thoughts too.
Mark
Thank you Mark. I found the Scotia article very interesting and I think I’m doing everything right there. The information on your Dividends page link was also a great recap for me. I’m about 5 years out from Retirement so I’m trying to get my ducks in a row. I found your other site ‘Cashflows and Portfolios’ retirement projections super useful and valuable and the results let me sleep well at night. I’ll be in touch to run my Retirement scenario again soon to re-evaluate my order of withdrawals. Cheers
Sounds like a plan, Alice. Reach out to Cashflows whenever you wish and all returning members get a big discount too! It’s just the way my partner (Joe ) and I work and want to reward folks.
As I approach some semi-retirement, I have a few nerves for sure. I don’t know anyone that doesn’t feel a bit of trepidation. That said, I use the following for some sleep-at-night factors:
1. I won’t stop working at everything, just scaling back in 2025. We’ll see what happens in 2026.
2. I am growing our cash wedge such that RRSP/registered withdrawals won’t touch any equities for at least a year – just in case markets go down a lot.
3. I have a plan to “live off dividends” from our non-reg. accounts for a few years – not touching the capital/letting capital compound.
4. If really necessary, although not fun, I could scale back spending although it would mean less travel and discretionary spending.
What I’m guarding against the most is poor returns/sequence of return risks (SORR). A retiree must confront at least two issues if not three if they are not prepared:
1. capital must be sold for income needs,
2. the smaller capital account that remains will compound less, and depending on inflation,
3. you have less aforementioned purchasing power long-term.
Keep me posted if you need anything and thanks for your comments. Always great to engage with other DIY investors and see what they are up to.
Mark
Thank you Mark. I agree the biggest worry for me when retiring will be the sequence of returns risk, it really is a crap shoot. I like your sleep at night factors. Crazy to say, but maybe if Trump’s actions tank the market over the next few years I’ll feel better starting Retirement in 5 ish years knowing my odds are better in that regard. I can’t believe I’m asking for a correction/crash!
Yes, all bets are certainly off with him in power. Very sad times, really.
Stay financially and mentally well – not easy days to be reading the news!
Mark
I feel like you and I are at very similar stages Mark. My wife has been retired for 7 years but I’m just reducing my work load to a minimum now to keep me in the loop and to supplement what I hope is a successful retirement plan. I reached out a couple of days ago to let you know that I’d be looking to benefit from your services and I’ll be planning to prepare the necessary info to send through next week. I hope that your review of our planning reassures me that we’ll be just fine but I’m doing this now so that I have some time to adjust if required. I’m only just 56 so if I have to make some adjustments I likely have a little time left to correct the plan. The hope is to live comfortably and also leave a nice inheritance for our two boys. Fingers crossed. 🤞
Happy to support you, Paul – with a discount too of course. (Replied.) 🙂
There is always a one-more-year kinda thing for us but my wife and I decided there is so much more to the world than full-time work, so she transitioned to 3-days per week last year and I’m hoping to catch up and start that in a few short months in early 2025.
I like my work and what I contribute to (so does she) but also at the end of the day controlling my/our time is a far greater goal and gift than more money in the bank.
Looking forward to sharing more details with you and helping you out.
Have a great weekend,
Mark