Dividends

This blog is about saving and investing my way to a $1 million portfolio.  This is our desired investment portfolio excluding workplace pensions, ignoring our government pensions (CPP or OAS), ignoring any part-time work or income derived from hobbies like this blog.  Very aggressive I know but doable!  Read on 🙂

Why my goal to live off dividends remains alive and well.

Can you have too much income from dividends?  (Heck no.)

Why dividend investing works for me – period.

A major part of our investment strategy to accomplish this $1 million goal is via dividend investing in some key accounts.  Here is our chart as of December 2018:

Dividend Income December 2018

We believe earning $30,000 per year in tax-free (thanks TFSA) and tax-efficient (taxable account) dividend income will cover most of our basic living expenses for as long as we live.

Here are some examples of what this $30,000 per year in dividend income, growing over time thanks to dividend increases alone, should cover in 2019 dollars for the rest of our lives:

  • food/groceries, basic household supplies = $8,000 per year or $667/mo.
  • condo utilities (heat, hydro, water, internet, cell phone bills) = $6,000 per year or $500/mo.
  • condo property taxes = $6,000 per year or $500/mo.
  • condo fees = $6,000 per year or $500/mo.
  • 1 car (insurance ($50-100) + gas ($50-100) + maintenance = $3,000 per year or $250/mo.
  • healthcare costs (various).

________________

$30,000 per year and more every year without touching the capital.  I look forward to it!

Why dividends?

When a corporation declares a dividend, the company’s retained earnings decrease and its current liabilities increase. When the cash dividend is paid, the corporation’s cash account decreases.  Dividend payments directly reduce a company’s earnings, so only stable, well-established companies tend to make regular dividend payments.

Why would companies pay dividends at all?

Great question actually.  Companies use dividends to pass on their profits directly to shareholders. They don’t have to but many companies do. A few reasons come to mind for me:

  • Reason #1 – it is core to company strategy. Potentially there are no current companies to acquire, maybe company debt is under control, and/or there is already a healthy stream of cash to begin funding new company products or services.  Thus, as part of company strategy to reward shareholders – the board of directors feels it’s simply one of the best things to do with company profits over time.
  • Reason #2 – the company is on sound financial ground. Most companies that pay a dividend, especially long-term (as in decades) have a stable business model.  You really can’t fake dividend payments for very long.  Companies that grow their dividend tend to have great cash flow – profits.  As an investor, it’s to your advantage to own shares in a company that makes large profits, consistently, with time. A reliable dividend is essentially one very good sign of business strength.  This is because unstable companies cannot divert profits directly to shareholders for very long.
  • Reason #3 – they want to attract investors. This is akin to company strategy.  Some investors are more speculative and like risks (note: this is not me).  Dividend-paying companies can attract a certain type of investor; one who prefers cash in hand versus the hope of capital gains.  Such investors like the idea of earning income from their investments the same way people go to work to earn an income – it’s dependable.  Over time the work is performed by their portfolio.  The portfolio will pay out MORE income over time if you reinvest dividends and/or you hold such dividend paying companies long enough whereby dividends are increased by the company every year or so.  Companies know there are investors out there who put a bias on income generated from their portfolio over growth.
  • Reason #4 – companies know investors like optionality. You see, in a perfect world, all businesses would allocate capital in a way to perfectly maximize the return on that capital.  This would be done so reinvested money would go back into the business in way that pays off immensely for the shareholder (by increasing returns over time AND by continually reducing the company’s tax burden).  But you should know by now we don’t live in a perfect world.  This means shareholders have over time demanded a dividend – for the purposes of “optionality”.  That old link I provided above tells us shareholders like optionality – and dividends provide that optionality – to give investors the choice to increase or decrease their exposure to the business.  Reinvested dividends therefore, take advantage of that optionality, to increase exposure.  Dividends taken as cash, do not.

Dividends are therefore one very important part of an investor’s total return.  An investor could technically create their own dividend (income stream) by timing the sale of their stock shares during times of market jubilance, leveraging stock price appreciation.  This may or may not appeal to some investors.

Dividend Slide

Can we live on just $30,000 in dividends per year?

No.  Although that income plus the following should provide a comfortable retirement in our 50s, 60s and beyond:

  • We’ll start to draw down our RRSP assets in our early 50s.  (We figure we could likely draw down our RRSPs to the tune of $20,000 per year, for 20 years, to supplement the $30,000 per year in growing dividend income earned from investments inside our TFSAs and non-registered account.)

________________

$50,000 per year in retirement

Can we live on $50,000 per year?  Very close.

  • Even after we realize our $30,000 dividend income goal, and while we draw down our RRSPs to the tune of $20,000 per year for the next 20 years, we’ll still work.  Why?  We want to keep our bodies and minds active.
  • We would like to work part-time starting at age 50 and earn about $10,000-$20,000 net income per year, each.  That would be ideal.
  • $30,000 per year will cover basic necessities.
  • $20,000 per year from RRSPs will cover some wants in semi-retirement.
  • Part-time work should cover the rest!

________________

$70,000 per year in retirement

Can we live on $70,000 per year?  I absolutely think so!

  • Assuming 1) we have our desired, base, $30,000 dividend income goal, 2) we’re drawing down our RRSPs in our 50s and 60s to the tune of $20,000 per year AND 3) assuming we work part-time for a few years in our 50s that should be enough. 
  • As RRSPs disappear throughout our 50s and 60s we’ll replace that income with our pensions.
  • We intend to take our workplace pensions in our 60s to avoid any early retirement withdrawal penalties and to allow those investments to grow more with time. My defined benefit workplace pension should payout just north of $30,000 per year at age 65, indexed for life.  My wife’s pension should at least be half that amount as well.  We’ll draw on these workplace pensions when our RRSPs are depleted in our 60s and beyond.

________________

Goal:  $70,000 per year net income in retirement

________________

At least $70,000 per year in net income in retirement – without debt – we can absolutely live on that 😉

My Boring Dividend Investing Approach

  1. I buy Canadian and U.S. companies that pay dividends.  I don’t own any company that doesn’t pay a dividend.
  2. I have a bias to owning companies that have a long history of increasing their dividends over decades or generations.
  3. I reinvest the dividends paid every month and quarter.
  4. I try to avoid selling any company regardless how far the stock price falls.  If anything I buy more stock when prices tank.  It’s like getting stuff on sale.
  5. I use low-cost Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) to invest in other countries from around the world.

What Canadian stocks do I own?

Most of the same stocks in the big mutual funds and ETFs of course.  Look at huge ETFs like XIU and XEI and VDY.  They own the very same stocks in different amounts!

  • These are banks (examples:  RY, TD, BNS, BMO, CM).
  • These are insurance companies (examples:  SLF, MFC, GWO).
  • These are pipeline companies (examples:  ENB, TRP).
  • These are telecommunications companies (examples:  BCE, T).
  • These are energy companies (like SU).
  • These are utilities (examples:  FTS, EMA, AQN).

Basically, I buy companies that people need.

People need to bank, so I own banks.

People need insurance, so I own insurance companies.

Last time I checked people want to heat and cool their home(s); they love the internet and their cell phones, so I buy utility companies.  You get the idea I think.

I also own a number of Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) (examples:  REI.UN, HR.UN, CAR.UN) because real estate traditionally goes up in value long-term; residential real estate and commercial real estate included.

My investing process is rather simple really.

  1. Buy and hold these companies.
  2. Reinvest dividends paid. 
  3. Relax.  Do nothing.  Wait.  
  4. Reinvest dividends (again) next month and quarter.
  5. Wait some more.  Watch more income roll in.  
  6. Rinse and repeat until wealthy.

What U.S. stocks do I own?

In recent years I’ve gravitated to owning more U.S.-listed ETFs for low-cost investing, to help simplify my portfolio and to sleep easy at night knowing I own hundreds of stocks for a very low fee.  However, as you know by now, I also like growing dividend income.  So, I will continue to own some U.S. stocks for dividend income and dividend growth.  Those stocks include Johnson & Johnson (JNJ) and Procter & Gamble (PG).

Beyond a few U.S. stocks I own low-cost U.S. ETFs for extra diversification in my RRSP and always will.

What do I hold where?

I hold Canadian dividend paying stocks in my non-registered (taxable) account and inside our Tax Free Savings Accounts (TFSAs).  Why?

Canadian dividend-paying stocks receive favourable tax treatment from our government.  These stocks are eligible for the Canadian dividend tax credit if left unregistered (outside TFSA and RRSP accounts).  The plan is to own up to 40 Canadian dividend paying stocks for tax-friendly (taxable account) and tax-free (TFSA) dividend income.

I keep a few U.S. dividend paying stocks in my RRSP.  Why?

Like I wrote to you above, I hold a few U.S. blue-chip stocks for U.S. dollar income and long-term growth.  Unfortunately U.S-dividend paying stocks do not receive any favourable tax treatment from our Canadian government.  I keep U.S. stocks inside an RRSP to avoid paying any withholding taxes (15%).

Other than the intention to own a few U.S. stocks inside my RRSP I invest in low-cost U.S.-listed ETFs.  We will continue to use ETFs more over time inside our RRSPs leading up to early retirement.

What to invest where?

I do not/will not hold U.S. stocks in a Canadian non-registered account.  Why?

Here is a summary of what I’ve learned:

  • U.S. stocks held within RRSP or LIRA or RRIF = no withholding taxes.
  • U.S. stocks held within RESP or TFSA = pay 15% withholding taxes.
  • U.S. stocks held unregistered accounts = pay 15% withholding taxes (which is recoverable at time of tax filing).

This is why I keep U.S. stocks inside my RRSP:  no withholding taxes on U.S. dividends.  This is not the case when you hold U.S. dividend stocks in a non-registered account.  In a non-registered account you’ll pay:

  • 15% U.S. withholding tax off the top AND
  • because U.S. dividends don’t qualify for the Canadian dividend tax credit, you’ll pay tax at your marginal rate on the full amount of the dividend.  U.S. dividends held in a non-registered account are taxed like interest income.  Thankfully, for U.S. stocks in non-registered accounts, you get a credit for the amount withheld when you file your tax return.  This credit can be applied against Canadian income taxes so in most cases that leaves you square—providing your Canadian tax rate is at least 15%.

I keep Canadian REITs in my TFSA or RRSP exclusively.  Why?

Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) are companies that invest in real estate assets and distribute their income (primarily from rent) to shareholders, usually in the form of dividends, return of capital, and income. While it depends on the REIT, if the REIT distributes a portion of their income as return of capital, interest, capital gains or dividends, each portion will be taxed accordingly.  Keeping REITs inside a TFSA or RRSP avoids this tax complication.

My Asset Location Preferences

Non-registered account:  Canadian dividend paying stocks; take advantage of the dividend tax credit.  In Ontario, you can earn about $50,000 in dividend income tax-free provided you have no other income to report.  Incredible really.

TFSAs:  Canadian dividend paying stocks and Canadian REITs; no dividend tax credit but at least tax-free income.

RRSPs:  U.S. dividend paying stocks and U.S.-listed ETFs; no withholding taxes, USD dividends and long-term capital appreciation via equity ETFs.

Want some help starting your investing research?

Consider researching the top holdings the big ETFs and mutual funds own in their top-10 or 20 holdings.

Consider subscribing to my partners at 5iResearch. 5i Research, is a proud partner of My Own Advisor, who provides unbiased information on the top companies and ETFs to own in Canada.  As a My Own Advisor reader, I’ve arranged for you to have instant full-access, for free, to all of 5i’s research reports, all the model portfolios, and access to their archive of over 57,000 answered investment questions.

5i Research

Thanks for visiting and make sure you subscribe to my site!