Weekend Reading – Generating Your Retirement Income
How are you going to generate your retirement income?
Today’s post will share some of my brief thoughts on that as a newly minted retiree myself as part of a new pillar post on this site that I hope to refresh over time, annually.
But first, some general retirement planning options to consider:
Option #1 – Save more
I doubt most people will like this option but it’s probably necessary to mention. Canadians are living longer on average and you’ll need money if you’re sticking around. Saving more money and growing a larger nest egg to drawdown will undoubtedly help combat inflationary pressures, rising healthcare costs and any longevity risk. Which brings me to option #2.
Option #2 – Work longer
If you didn’t like option #1, you may not like this one! Working longer into your 60s or potentially your 70s might be the reality for a good percentage of Gen X and Y. Part of the reason these cohorts will need to work longer is because many Boomers remain in the workforce so they can fund their retirement. That’s continually squeezing the job market – some Boomers are not retiring at age 63 or 64 any longer. They continue to work to fund their lifestyle, pay off debt or pad their accounts. Some Boomers are continuing to work because they enjoy it. Others are continuing to work because they absolutely have to.
Option #3 – Spend less
The 4% rule tells us we should be “safe” to withdraw approximately 4% of our portfolio with a minimal chance of running out of money. With low interest rates sustained, crappy bond yields now, I think there needs to be some new retirement math – even though the 4% rule remains a decent starting point for your retirement withdrawal math.
With the ol’ 4% rule any retiree would need $1-million invested to produce a steady income of $40,000 a year.
If none of these options really appeal to you, then you need to consider if you have “enough” already to retire on and ideally, if that portfolio covers your retirement income needs and wants.
Generating Your Retirement Income

Retirement (I’m certain) will bring many life changes for us – not just extra time for some golf or travel or to try new hobbies.
Now that we’re both no longer working, we’ll need to rely on our investments to generate meaningful cash flow. That could mean changing the way you manage your portfolio – or in our case, not at all.
Common industry expert wisdom has shared the following:
“…But just because you’ll be making withdrawals doesn’t mean you need to make a fundamental shift in your investment strategy. This idea often worries investors who use exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or mutual funds for their stock holdings. They may believe these “growth-oriented” funds are no longer appropriate and feel they should switch to dividend funds, or even individual dividend stocks when they retire.” – MoneySense
AND more recently from Morningstar expert Christine Benz:
“For most of my career, I was squarely on Team Total Return. I liked dividends as much as the next person, but I agreed with the conventional academic wisdom: Focusing on dividend-payers narrows your opportunity set and, in turn, your portfolio’s long-term return potential. Better to build a portfolio with the best possible risk/reward characteristics, encompassing both dividend-payers and non-dividend-payers, and when it comes time to withdraw from it, pull cash flows from whatever cash flow source makes the most sense. In some markets, that might mean spending dividends, and in others, spending capital gains might be more advantageous.” – Morningstar
Those expert opinions are valid but we’ve chosen not to change our portfolio leading into retirement – and I don’t anitcipate we’ll change it very much in early retirement now either.
Here’s why…
I believe our approach to generating retirement income has always had the best of both worlds:
- We own many Canadian stocks that tend to grow their dividends, increasing our income, and
- We own low-cost ETFs for total return too.
It’s called hybrid investing and a term I coined almost 15-years ago to describe the mixed approach to DIY investing – owning individual stocks and ETFs that deliver income and growth.
Experts have long since argued that every investor should take a holistic approach when it comes to investing – diversifying across dividend-payers and non-dividend-payers alike. But that approach ignores real investor behaviour and tangible income needs in a really volatile investing world leading up to retirement and then during retirement.
Cashing a dividend cheque (or having dividends sent to the cash portion of our accounts every month like we have…) is simply easier than venturing into your portfolio to figure out what to sell / when to sell broad-market ETFs on their own.
Selling involves decisions and timing.
As per the recent Morningstar article referenced above that I will link to later, selling might feel bad.
So, given the natural tension of selling off assets as you age it’s no surprise to me why many retirees (including thousands of readers of this site!) anchor their portfolios in dividend-paying stocks and build around those. It’s not unlike some retirees setting up their own 60/40 portfolio – to take advantage of the fixed-income portion – using the 40% fixed income allocation for living needs during volatile equity market swings.
And if you own an all-in-one ETF in that 60/40 portfolio construction it will absolutely require you to sell your beloved “BAL” / balanced ETF units which may or may not feel too good during reckless market conditions.
Generating Your Retirement Income
At the end of the day, these are some retirement income facts:
- Total return relies on all types of investment growth (dividends, interest and realized capital gains), and
- This total return only approach of just selling your assets in retirement, may or may not appeal to everyone.
For me/us, cashflow has always been the focus to retire on. That is, the sum of dividends, distributions and where necessary in good time, yes of course, selling assets in our portfolio.
This is because while ideal to some, to just “live off dividends” (and distributions), if you never eat some capital it will just keep growing.
You’ll never run out of money.
Never running out of money means you are either focused on creating a huge estate or huge taxation burden or both. It also means during your lifetime you could have spent more of your money on experiences or people you love.
The reality is that most retirees will have to draw on some of their capital throughout their retirement to meet their spending needs and wants, and to combat inflation. In fact, if they want to live their best lives they probably should anyhow.
I welcome your thoughts on this total return / income generation debate. One without end in the personal finance blogosphere. 🙂
Weekend Reading – Generating Your Retirement Income
Here is the Morningstar reference I based this latest post on – a good read: Why Christine Benz has changed her tune with dividend paying stocks.
Further Reading:
Check out dozens of free Retirement stories and essays you can learn from here.
Instead of focusing on the 4% rule I mentioned above, you can drawdown your portfolio via Variable Percentage Withdrawal (VPW) which means spending more money in good years, curtailing discretionary spending in bad years.
Enjoy some FREE retirement calculators such as my personal favourites here.
Want some personalized help, well beyond what some basic free tools could ever offer?
My partner and I at Cashflows & Portfolios offer low-cost retirement projections solutions to support your retirement readiness and planning ideas – to any DIY investors supported by DIY investors.
Learn more here!
Mark

Hey Mark,
I realized reading this post, and some of your replies that I’m a bit confused by your approach.
My understanding of the cash wedge was to have x months / years of spending in place ** in case of poor market performance **. This approach can avoid the need to sell equities in a bear market. You’ve said you have this year’s spending, and next year’s already in cash, and that’s how you’ll fund the next couple of years. But, I was thinking you would take the current “uber” bear market and potentially sell some equities while stocks are hitting (near) all-time highs, and keep that wedge for the possible “rainy day” down the road.
This is in no way a criticism, I’m just looking to understand your future steps. If you spend down your cash that you have now, but then there is in fact a bear market in late 2027 (or even sooner), then won’t you be forced to sell some depressed equities then? I feel like I must be missing something. For us, I’m not sure we’ll even have much opportunity to develop a cash wedge, other than 3 – 6 months of dividends ahead of our retirement, but I’m still curious to better understand how you’re implementing it.
Generally, I wonder what the criteria is to say “now, I should sell” or “now, I should be using my cash wedge”. To me, it seems there is great potential to only identify those events in hindsight.
Happy to provide more context.
I’m using a bucket approach for retrirement. Older post that I will update this year.
https://www.myownadvisor.ca/our-bucket-approach-to-earning-income-in-retirement/
A cash wedge and a bucket approach are similar (they both are designed to protect retirement income spending from equity volatility) but they differ a bit:
1. Cash wedge is a specialized version of the bucket approach, focused on 1–3 years of cash, while the bucket approach can be a broader, multi-stage strategy that consists of more than 2 phases, usually 3 or can be even 5 phases.
2. Think of the cash wedge as the essential bucket #1 in any bucket strategy.
3. How you structure Buckets #2 and #3 or 2-5 is more optional to you…
Thoughts?
Mark
Okay. Thanks. I forgot about the bucket strategy which you have discussed many times. I visualize it like a cash conveyor belt. Ha!
I guess my question then is mostly focussed on how you plan to execute Bucket three? Will there be any specific market criteria to trigger asset sales to replenish the middle bucket? That sort of sounds like market timing, and that’s not really the discussion I’m trying to have but I’ve always thought of the cash wedge as more of a down market buffer and now that you’re putting the bucket approach into practice I can see they aren’t quite the same thing, but also similar in some ways.
Ha, good stuff.
Some cash wedge/cash position always as Bucket #1. It’s a must per se in my book for us. Not negotiable…
How you struture the other buckets is up to you. Some folks might just have two buckets:
1. Cash wedge/Bucket #1,
2. 60/40 ETF.
Other investors might have three buckets:
1. Cash wedge/Bucket #1,
2. Bonds?
3. All-in-one equity ETF/”EQT” fund.
Again, lots of variations. Not right or wrong. Whatever folks need to work for them.
In my opinion many options with Buckets (1-3, 1-4, 1-5??) but Bucket #1 is always the cash/cash equivalents portion needed for spending near-term.
How big even Bucket #1 is or is not is variable since, as an example, some readers and fans of this site are earning well over $100k per year in dividend income and feel they don’t need much cash on hand. Meaning, the large cashflow generated by their portfolio is more than enough for all living expenes….so the safety is WAY down because of that already and why keep too much cash on hand when annual cashflow already exceeds expenses??
Again, that may or may not be you or most people!
Cheers.
I forgot to answer your other questions…
1. I haven’t figured out bucket #3 yet to be honest (with my ETFs). I figure selling some ETF units (3% withdrawal rate?) every few years or so near market-highs will be good. Using a 60/40 ETF, that’s the plan anyhow, you sell some off all the time x1 or x2 per year without fail. No market timing – just do it.
https://www.myownadvisor.ca/can-you-retire-using-a-60-40-portfolio/
2. For me, and what expert literature suggests, the cash wedge is always bucket #1 in a bucket approach. If you don’t touch it at all, that’s like some sort of very large emergency fund. The idea for most is to spend the money from your portfolio in retirement. 🙂
Cheers!
Hi Mark
Do you and your wife have non registered joint account set up? I read the pros and cons of both and was wondering your thoughts?
I’ve considered this.
https://www.moneysense.ca/save/investing/individual-vs-joint-investment-accounts/
Thoughts?
Someone you are pursuing?
Mark
IMHO, the psychological aspect of having divvies just flow monthly into your account without having to think about it – and without having to sell off any of the “fountain” that is producing them is huge. Eventually – sure – I’ll start selling assets but that’s not something I have to worry about in my early years of retirement.
I like it myself but I know others feel differently. All good!
I’m retired (early) now because of how I invested so I’m biased. 🙂
Agreed. 2% yield is hard to live off.
This topic can generate endless discussion because people are somewhere on a spectrum from “die with zero” to “never touch the principal”. It’s a personal preference and we also need to adapt strategies depending on our financial situation.
100% agreed!
As always, “it depends” but certainly spending some yield and some capital is the path for most unless you want to build an estate.
Hi Mark,
I was too early in the morning and I accidentally posted my comment (https://www.myownadvisor.ca/weekend-reading-generating-your-retirement-income/#comment-156522) under my full name. Would you mind removing my comment for privacy reasons?
Thanks!
Done!
It is always good to revisit these staples every now and then it made me have another look …I’m not flip flopping yet:)
I still don’t view BAL/GRO/EQT type funds as suitable for our retirement simply because they do not generate enough income and offer lower risk adjusted returns vs. other options. Selling assets esp. early in retirement is not for me and frankly not a strategy that consistently works well enough, you can ignore sequence of return risk at your own peril. I realize many folks do it’s about a simple as it gets but simplicity also has a cost. You can make it work but it does require a very different mindset. I very much differentiate between pre an post retirement when it comes to our investment portfolio they are quite different. I now prioritize income and risk adjusted returns over total returns, none are mutually exclusive you can create decent income from lower risk investments that generate good total returns they are just not all in one solutions.
The discussion on how much to withdraw will be a perpetual one. I know you and many readers are quite conservative which given your “noob” retirement status and long retirement window makes a lot of sense. I started the same way (2022 was not an ideal year let me tell you) and since have found I can take out quite a bit more, 6+%.but the markets have been very kind. It will be interesting to follow your experience here.
As per Mr. Bengen himself the 4% rule (the max safe withdrawal rate assuming the absolute worst conditions imaginable) is outdated, inaccurate and imo misleading. Real world data (Bengen 2.0) puts it closer to 5% for a 40 year period and higher if you shorten the time frame. He uses US data so transpose it to Canada and you might be looking at a higher number still given our higher yields and sizable quality of life gap (for starters minor medical events do not lead to financial ruin). The difference between 4% and say 5.5% in years is not insignificant the risk delta on the other hand is imo.
I enjoyed your comment, Ben.
SORR / Sequence of Returns Risk is very real IMO. I don’t want to be selling assets when they are down -10% or more in price and we haven’t had a bad bear market for some time, so it will happen again, just don’t know when…nor for how long.
I’ve always prioritized cashflow for us to retire on – which made the decision about us being financially independent clear.
My magic number was 5% annualized returns. So, I knew if we could structure the portfolio in a way whereby 5% long-term annualized returns (sum of dividends, interest, capital gains, etc.) would occur, meaning, over the next 30-40 years we should be able to get >5% returns over the coming decades, then we should be “good”.
I expect our portfolio of stocks + global ETFs should achieve that 5% mix.
Even if it doesn’t, for some very odd reason, taking out 4%-5% returns from the existing portfolio (i.e., a safe withdrawal rate) should last us our lifetime.
If we get more than 5% returns, over time, say we average closer to 6% or 7%, then we need to spend more otherwise the portfolio will just keep growing.
So, I prioritize the sum of dividends, distributions and eventually selling off portions of our portfolio = cashflow = to achieve the 5% which should meet all needs, all wants with some buffer.
It will be interesting to post my experiences here too!!
Thanks for following and engaging.
Ever since I started investing – 30 years ago – I have always concentrated on dividend paying stocks. In hindsight I wish I took more risk when younger, but I don’t think I could have known what to buy. I went the dividend route as a growth approach requires knowing what to buy and when to sell. It’s pretty easy to pick a good combination of 15-25 dividend stocks and just let them run. For me, it simply drastically reduced the time spent thinking about our portfolio. Seems to have worked out as our dividend income is about $185k. The only capital we sell is for minor tax planning. If we die with a big tax bill…so be it.
I hear ya, Mark. I should have taken on more individual stock risk in my 20s and 30s but such is life. Live and learn.
That is incredible you are earning about $185k per year in dividend income.
What stocks are you holding now/these days?
Is your basket of stocks about 15-25?
We’re at 25 Canadian stocks only and 2 low-cost ETFs for equities these days.
We own the 5 banks, PPL, ENB, CNR, WCP, T, PHX, BRE, BIP.UN, EMA, FRU, MFC, POW, SOBO, TRP. 19 holdings in total. While not all annually increase their payout, most do so I don’t worry about inflation. I used to invest in some US stocks, but currency risk and that market just seems wilder so I exited it. I don’t do much trading, maybe a few times a year when I see a yield switch opportunity. I am happy with the mix today. Ideally I would like to trim some bank holdings as I think they are expensive but I don’t see much switching opportunities of interest. I can sleep at night with this mix and it does not take much time out of my life to manage it – to me, this is a huge benefit of the dividend approach, particularly if you can generate enough to fund your chosen lifestyle.
Nice, Mark.
Impressive portfolio – so just the existing 19 CDN stocks and no USD stocks or international stocks via ETFs either? I think I remember you sharing that – no need for extra stocks or ETFs given your high cashflow for existing CDN stocks ala Tom Connolly approach. 🙂
We own 7 CDN banks, I own EQB for growth and have done so for well over 5 years now, up well over 100% since we’ve owned it.
I also like the pipleines.
I’m also a fan of WCP. Been on a nice run…
We own quite a bit of Brookfield companies too.
So, overall, very similar to you with some exceptions for growth vs. income.
I see your point on trimming CDN banks but I wouldn’t fix what isn’t broken personally. I’m trying to do the same and less tinkering with the portfolio.
Do you keep any sort of cash wedge/cash set aside for near-term spending? Maybe not needed if cashflow is so good?
Cheers,
Mark
Hi Mark,
Did you consider creating a “bond tent” for your early years of retirement to protect against bad initial sequence of returns? This reduces exposure to selling during downturns during the early years of retirement. Sure you sacrifice some upside but IMO, retirement isn’t about optimizing wealth growth anymore, it’s about ensuring sufficient income for the rest of your life. I mentioned in the comments in your previous post about me having 10+ years in “safe assets” to protect from bad early year sequence of returns. That’s my “bond tent” that I will use if the sequence of returns are bad in the next few years that will prevent selling equities at a low price. During later years, my cash/bond holding will decrease since longevity risk isn’t as high and I’m pretty much investing for heirs.
Hey Phillip, I did but I prefer my cash wedge approach to keep more of my portfolio working during all times.
https://www.myownadvisor.ca/how-much-cash-should-you-keep/
Via this approach, there is nothing I need to sell (unless I want to) for the rest of 2026 and throughout 2027.
If SORR is bad/bad sequence of returns until 2028, doesn’t matter, I won’t be selling anything since cash in place already for all spending.
Thoughts?
Mark
My thought is personal finance is personal. You keep 2 years of safe assets and I keep 10. I guess I saved more for piece of mind whereas I can put a lot in cash and short-term bonds yet still have a large share of equity holdings. IMO, what’s important is knowing why you’re doing what you’re doing, then do what you think is best for you.
Very personal. I think your 10 years is VERY safe of course and nothing wrong with that at all if that approach meets your needs.
100% aligned.
Mark
Good article, Mark.
The Morningstar lady might want to know about a stock I bought 5 years ago at $46: ENB which is now $75 plus the dividend, and approximately 7% YOC after 5 years. I’ll take that any day. Now can you imagine a well constructed dividend growth portfolio ala Henry Mah/Tom Connolly?
I don’t think I ever asked you why you eschew “professional” asset management.
Personally I’m getting to the point where I think going “professional” might save me a lot of concern about “protecting” and growing our assets. It’s just that damn fee, even at 1% (plus tax) rubs me the wrong way.
Thanks for your comment, Don!
Yes, the last 5-years have been good for ENB but it’s actually less than the total return of XIU over the same period.
Same goes with XAW and other low-cost ETFs.
That said, ENB is doing well but not all stocks do as well as ENB. Some better. Some worse!
I’m actually not against professional money management whatsoever. I have that on my FAQs page. Just that you need to get lots of value for the money there and many don’t. 1% fees + taxes is a lot to give up per year if your portfolio is north of $2M.
https://www.myownadvisor.ca/faqs/
Thanks for the comment!
Hi Mark, I find this to be an interesting topic. A couple things that I think about with regards to the topic is how much do I need at the time and does it bother me if when I pass I have a larger estate left behind. In a way both of these are related. Like yourself I have retired early (a little over 2 years now) so my investments need to last even longer than if I retired at say 65.
Over the past couple of years I have been taking an amount out of my investments that are over 85% (net income to net retirement income) of my last full year’s working income. As my expenses have been reduced; costs of commuting to work, lunches at work, clothes for work, mortgage payment, etc. this level of income more than meets all my needs including increased travel. Now this level of income is covered almost fully by dividends generated by my investments. I supplement a little by writing some covered calls on a couple stocks I own specifically for the purpose of writing covered calls. With the run up in the market my portfolio has increased in value as the individual stocks or ETFs go up but I do not need to sell as my needs and current wants are more than covered, my bank balance has actually been going up with unspent income that I have been taking from my investment accounts (LIF and RIF).
As for having a larger portfolio when I pass, I guess I have always been more worried about not having enough than leaving behind too much. It is a balancing act and I would think that if the money generated from dividends was ever short I would take some capital gains and reduce my portfolio when needed. This to me is an option but it is not something that is automatic that I would sell off part of my portfolio each year, it is more to balance needs in a specific year, hopefully not in a down market. Something I have been looking at and will be doing later this year is reducing money held in my locked in account (LIF) and moving it to my TFSA. This will help reduce the tax burden on any money left as I try to plan for it through where the money is actually held.
The other thing I have been looking at is selling off specific stocks and ETFs that have run up over the past few years and finding new places to invest that money. I have a few that I bought when the market was down and now they are getting to a point where they are looking over valued. I know it isn’t the best plan to try and time the market and I really am not trying to do that, I am just trying to manage some parts of my portfolio that have run up more than expected, especially with dividend paying ETFs and stocks which usually have a smaller range with which they trade.
Hope you have been enjoying the beginnings of your retirement.
“ Cashing a dividend cheque (or having dividends sent to the cash portion of our accounts every month like we have…) is simply easier than venturing into your portfolio to figure out what to sell / when to sell broad-market ETFs on their own.”
Struggling with this claim. In December you sell whatever your investment policy tells you to sell to replenish yoir cash reserves. Its can be “sell $200K worth of VBAL and move proceeds to a HISA”. What can possibly be easier than this? And the divs get reinvested automatically throughout the year.
Just 1 action per year, and you know exactly where you stand; don’t even need to look at your investment accounts, except in December and at tax time.
I can buy the argument that div investing might help psychologically but not the simplicity claim because its the wrong way around.
Thanks, Mordko.
If you and others are comfortable with selling off your ETFs at any time – that’s great. Most investors struggle with any systematic selling even if just x1 per year. If you can tell me lots of investors that don’t struggle with selling assets I’m all ears. I haven’t heard of many. 🙂
“What can possibly be easier than this? ”
I found this pretty easy (past tense as I recently sold all my XEI in my RRIF and LIF) …..
Have XEI pay the distribution to my RRIF and LIF on the last working day of the month. On the 15th of the following month, TDDI automatically withheld 20% for CRA and then put the 80% balance into my chequeing account at TD. Loved the monthly income showing up!
Zero action, zero decisions. Ain’t saying it’s the best, or suitable for everyone, but it was pretty darn easy.
Good stuff, Lloyd. I know many fans/readers of this site do the same.
Own some XEI (or a set basket of stocks pays distributions or dividends) such that:
1. cash builds up, so
2. cash withdrawn, and therefore,
3. cash used for living expenses.
Zero things to think about.
Still others sell a bit of XEI every few years, do the same 1-2-3.
Lots of ways to go about things and as long as you have a plan that works for your needs and wants, well, perfect.
That’s a really good example of the real problem with dividend investment strategy.
Since VBAL was established in 2018, XEI and VBAL had almost the sane return (VBAL slightly higher).
However in 2020 VBAL dropped by 1/5 while XEI dropped by over a third of its value. You are basically taking on more risk for similar return. And if you had the same risk and 100% allocation to stocks but not concentrated in Canadian divs, you would have been much richer.
In other words simplicity is a bit of red herring but inefficiency is real. That said, you do get the advantage of monthly payouts and if that’s really important then its a good strategy.
“In other words simplicity is a bit of red herring”
Sorry, I guess I misunderstood *your* question about what can possibly be easier. My bad.
Sorry, let me clarify. Simplicity was an assertion in the original post for the div strategy, so I explained why its a red herring. And yes, it is because nothing is easier when taking X dollars out of your total return ETF once a year.
You might recall VBAL returned a tidy -11% in 2022.
XEI was flat and still paid out distributions that same year.
The challenge with selecting timeframes is there is bias involved.
Generally speaking, over long timeframes, XEI investors will do just fine and so will VBAL, ZBAL, XBAL people.
Not right or wrong.
🙂
I’m not sure why anyone would even compare the past performance of a BAL ETF to a dividend equity ETF. It would be like comparing the performance of my Silverado versus my Trax. Trax gets much better MPG than the Silverado, but it sucks at hauling sheets of plywood. 😉
LOL. Fair. Totally different animals but they both get you to the same destination (A to B) which means long-term, likely similar long-term returns.
“ The challenge with selecting timeframes is there is bias involved.”
Absolutely. Which is why I didn’t. I picked maximum drawdown since VBAL was established. XEI had much larger drawdown, exactly as expected.
“ Over long timeframes, XEI investors will do just fine and so will VBAL…”
I tend to agree, but here is the kicker:
VBAL has lower risk. And for the similar risk to XEI, VEQT has higher expected return.
So its not that either approach is bad. They are both better than having cash under pillow. Its just that one of them is clearly suboptimal in risk/return terms.
Good stuff…re: not that either apporach is bad is the correct answer. 🙂
There are lots of ways to do much worse. We need to celebrate what is right when it comes to DIY investing vs. pointing out what could be wrong.
My best.
Hi Mark,
I wanted to comment on what you said about selling an all-in-one ETF:
> And if you own an all-in-one ETF in that 60/40 portfolio construction it will absolutely require you to sell your beloved “BAL” / balanced ETF units which may or may not feel too good during reckless market conditions.
You are not “stuck” in an all-in-one ETF and forced to sell all asset classes because you can sell the ETF and then buy back just the asset classes you want to retain. That way you can avoid permanently selling off a devalued asset class at a bad time.
Example: If you sell an all-in-one ETF inside a tax-deferred or tax-free account, then you can follow it up by buying back the 60% equities portion in a 100% equities ETF or the 40% fixed income portion in a 100% fixed income ETF. The end result is that you split your all-in-one ETF and kept either the equities or the fixed-income portion.
Doing this in an unregistered account has tax consequences. While it can be done, the effect is more complicated because of the capital gains tax due even on the portion that you reinvest again immediately.
Thanks for your comment, Stefan.
To help clarify my thoughts: for most investors in an all-in-one ETF, they will need to sell such all-in-one ETF to generate income – since 2% yield on these BAL or GRO or EQT funds will never be enough for spending.
You are never “stuck” in an all-in-one ETF (lots and lots and lots of ways to invest) but rather if you own just that, and many DIY investors do love all-in-one ETFs in many accounts, you would have to sell it to generate your cashflow.
Your option is a bit different, which I can appreciate!
Cheers,
Mark