Weekend Reading – Can you really retire on $500,000?

Weekend Reading – Can you really retire on $500,000?

Welcome to my latest Weekend Reading edition, wondering if you can really retire on $500,000???

I tackle that from a YouTuber in this edition and I share a bit more…

In case you missed the last Weekend Reading edition, working through retirement with higher inflation:

Weekend Reading – Retirement with higher inflation

And, I recently posted our latest dividend income update for retirement spending too!

July 2026 Dividend Income Update

Weekend Reading – Can you really retire on $500,000?

Thanks to my friends at TD Direct Investing for posting this interview below:

While recent surveys found that Canadians believe they need to save an average of $1.7 million to retire comfortably…(see link here)… the average Canadian aged 55 to 64 held just under $400,000 in liquid financial assets like workplace pensions and investments ahead of their retirement years…so seems like there is a big disconnect on retirement income needs and wants versus what folks really have – here in Canada at least.

And Duane from RetireEarly500K in the U.S. has a similar take, you don’t need a million bucks or more to retire there either, or do you??

Duane, thanks to some geoarbitrage of sorts moving from Los Angeles to the lower-cost Arizona desert using a 60/40 stock/bond portfolio mix retired on just over $500,000 invested in his late-50s. 

Some things I agreed with and not so much from Duane:

Agree:

  • I think his pessimistic view on higher inflation (closer to 4% over time) and lower nominal returns (before inflation) is smart planning overall. 
  • Seems Duane watches his money closely in retirement, which seems wise, and
  • Good on Duane to leave the workforce (if he was not happy!) and continue with his FIWOOT (Financial Independence, Work On Own Terms) YouTube channel passion project. You should try to retire to something…

I prefer Financial Independence Work On Own Terms (FIWOOT) versus FIRE

Now some things I struggled with from the guest on retirement income planning / his planning:

  • A shift into more bonds as he ages is likely not wise, given bonds are not as likely to keep up with inflation long-term – so Duane is likely going to have to re-think getting out of the stock market at age 73 like he mentioned, certainly so, if there is longevity. 
  • Although I don’t know Duane’s healthcare or healthcare insurance status, he might be surprised by any healthcare costs as he ages – so the longer he lives the more money he might need to support aging in place. The same would apply for Canadians to think about. 
  • He seems to rely on his YouTube channel for a good portion of his income, to support him spending a modest $3,000 after-tax per month. I know for me at My Own Advisor and with our new YouTube channel, that business income makes up a very, very small portion of our retirement income and we would be more than fine without any of it. This site and that channel are just fun passion projects. I hope you continue to enjoy them. 🙂

Can you really retire in Canada on just $500,000? 

You probably could but your ongoing, long-term, spending needs would be need to very modest like Duane, you might need a long-term passion project to retire to for income, and don’t forget about funding 1. needs + 2. wants + 3. including some buffer throughout retirement.

Money surprises can and likely will happen.

This is my simple retirement income planning formula.

Income Needs and Wants

More Weekend Reading – Beyond can you really retire on $500,000?

A thoughtful article on why dividend ETFs don’t work the way you think they do – but they still work well overall for income investors including moderating investor behaviour.

“Finally, do not dismiss the behavioural side of investing. If receiving a monthly or quarterly dividend helps you stay invested, avoid panic selling, and continue contributing during market downturns, that has genuine value. Compounding is sometimes easier to appreciate when investors see cash arriving and being reinvested rather than simply watching prices fluctuate on a screen.”

From my favourite thought-leadership newsletter, Farnam Street:

Henry Singleton on remaining flexible:

“I believe in maximum flexibility, so I reserve the right to change my position on any subject when the external environment relating to any topic changes too.”

A reader recently asked me about the The Bucket Approach to retirement income planning, as to avoid some advisor fees to figure it out. Well, this is a good overview.

I also posted this below on my site you can find that and related articles anytime in the Archives, very similar thinking and looking back, many years later, very interesting to see that I’ve largely followed this approach into early retirement today…

Our bucket approach to earning income in retirement

Happy investing and have a great weekend!

Mark

25 Responses to "Weekend Reading – Can you really retire on $500,000?"

  1. Hi Mark: Should you sell your investments? NO! Live off the dividends and each year they will increase in value. Could you retire today on $500k? Well I’m really not the one to ask as I started post work life on $400k but that was 34 years ago. I was laid off and didn’t get another job so early retirement at 43. The ’90’s were something like last year and about 5 1/2 years later I crossed the $1M. mark and like now investing all the way along. Bonds I have had my fill of. I bought bonds in the ’70’s during the high interest rate period after the Arab Oil Crises and since high interest rates lead to reduced prices I wasn’t going to sell for a loss so held them until they came due in ’92-’93. Mark I saw another sign that the market is at the top and is getting to turn. More dumb commentary. The title of the story in the Globe said “when did you go from a saver to an investor”. Well I thought this is really dumb. Naturally you had to save to invest so now you’re an investor but what if you want to invest more what do you have to do? That’s right you have to save more before you can invest more so my take is a main street investor is also a saver. Stories like this are a sure sign that writers are reaching for things to write about and taken with other articles of this ilk are sure signs that the market is at the top and has started to decline slightly if my portfolio is to be believed. Keep on investing Mark.

    Reply
    1. Well, we’ll see! 🙂

      You’ve done very well off $400k about 34 years ago!!

      My guess, what will happen in reality is we will sell off some “losers” in 2027 or 2028 and let some winners continue to run. I will keep you and others posted of course. In doing so, we’ll be tax-efficent too.

      You’re more experienced than I am but market stories are things to write about and have no reflection about what will really happen.

      I will keep investing, Ronald and by doing so, I suspect our dividend income might be higher later this year too!
      Cheers,
      Mark

      Reply
  2. You did get a nice little plug in:)

    Same, some things I can get with some not so much. Enjoyed the video I’ve seen similar ones and it’s good to provide other perspectives vs. the you need a gazillion $$ to retire. A couple of observations,

    1 If you run a YT channel bringing in >$30K you own a business you are not retired on $500K but FIWOOT-ing
    2} $500K in a 60/40 @4% gives you $20K py I doubt that’s enough given the official (be it bogus) US poverty threshold is $16K. He likely needs some YT income even if you add in Social Security. The numbers don’t add up making the premise of the video is a bit wonky.
    4} Managing your spend is probably the single biggest factor in retirement you can control. Most of the “need >$1M” claims are the result of lifestyle inflation. You do not need a $60k car nor a 3500 sqft house nor most of the useless stuff we believe we can’t live without. I do appreciate Duane’s take on this, modesty is a good trade off for time in my book. You do not need a lot of money to lead a rich life.
    5} Being too conservative too early would be a no for me as well, I’d consider it but likely only in my late 70’s you have to fight inflation for a long time still and bonds won’t do that. Imo 60/40 is already quite conservative.

    Ultimately $500K in the US would not give me a lot of confidence, $500K in Canada maybe.

    Reply
    1. Thanks for your comments, Ben.

      I think Duane’s income objectives are very different than ours for sure. All good. Everyone is different and I continue to say personal finance is personal but even with around $500k for him, I believe that might not be enough based on what he himself mentioned in his video with TD:

      1. There are longivity risks (cited his parents as examples),
      2. There are emergencies and healthcare risks (especially so in the U.S.), and
      3. If YT is a big portion of your income, which can be unstable, then there is that risk as well.

      I’m all for FIWOOT, I’m part of that, I don’t hide that and I’ve written about that myself here for years.

      https://www.myownadvisor.ca/i-prefer-financial-independence-work-on-own-terms-fiwoot-versus-fire/

      I’m a retiree but I blog for fun and now have a YT channel for fun.

      But I don’t need this site for retirement income and the YT channel doesn’t make a penny yet. It might, who knows? These are passion projects for me. I’m here to literally pay it forward and have some fun.

      That said, I don’t believe U.S. folks nor Canadians need $1M or more to retire, assuming the following of course:

      1. Most Canadians have modest spending needs. Retirement income planning always starts with what you intend to spend. Always. Duane in this case doesn’t spend a lot so he doesn’t need a lot but it’s not without risks for him as mentioned.
      2. Most Canadians have near MAX or >75% CPP for inflation-protection.
      3. Most Canadians will get near MAX OAS income for inflation-protection.
      4. Most Canadians can learn to use RRSP/RRIF for income and TFSAs for growth.
      5. Most Canadians can learn to be very flexible with retirement income spending = spend more in “good years” vs. curtail a bit of spending in “bad years”.
      6. Most Canadians will keep some cash/cash safety on hand, at all times, to be used as part of break-glass-in-case of an emergency.

      If they can do those key things, I believe, then you don’t need a lot per se if you don’t spend a lot.
      Mark

      Reply
  3. John from Stoney Creek · Edit

    Hi Mark
    Always interesting reading!

    I too am going to go off topic slightly. I’m 66 and my wife is 63. We are both retired.

    Our RIFs make up 60% of our total portfolio, with TFSA & non-registered making up 40%.

    We are focusing on winding down our RIFs to zero as fast as feasible (probably should have started this process years ago).

    We recently sold TFSA assets to fund a two year cash wedge. The cash wedge has been moved to our joint non-registered account.

    Reasoning: avoid sequence of returns risk, while also creating an opportunity to transfer our entire 2027 RIF withdrawal (the bulk of our 2027 taxable income) directly into our TFSAs with in-kind stock transfers.

    In a similar manner, we are cashing in the annual total of TFSA dividends at year end. Again, this is to maximize future RIF withdrawal amounts going directly in-kind to the TFSA (as opposed to going into the non-registered account).

    Hypothetically, our 2027 RIF in-kind stock transfer might be $70,000 in stock to each TFSA, and $25,000 each to income taxes. The income taxes paid take care of RIF withdrawal & non-registered account dividends and interest income earned.

    We plan to repeat this process for another 4 years until 2030 when I turn 70.

    Any thoughts on this as a drawdown strategy?

    Reply
    1. Nice to hear from you, John!

      First, I think you are wise to focus on registered accounts now in retirement. re: get those RRSPs/RRIFs down in value for three key reasons for the work I do at Cashflows & Portfolios:

      https://www.cashflowsandportfolios.com/

      1. Meet some of your income needs,
      2. Smooth out taxation over time from this tax-deferred account,
      3. Reduce taxation liabilities for the estate.

      Then, I like personally using Non-Reg. assets for some income but that’s because we have quite a bit of CDN stocks there for income.

      Third, finally, I like TFSA assets left-alone for emergencies, big capital needs in retirement, tax-free withdrawals as needed but TFSAs ideally left alone until your 80s or 90s for estate planning. TFSA = tax-free money to go with CPP and OAS as you age.

      Any money you don’t need from RRIF each year, goes into TFSA first, and then Non-Reg. second with anything leftover.

      So, generally speaking, taking down RRSP/RRIF in your 60s and 70s as to avoid lots of taxation and hoarding too much money into your 80s inside RRIFs/LIFs is a very wise move I believe.

      We are only in our early 50s now fully retired but I suspect our RRSPs/RRIFs, LIRAs turned into LIFs will be gone fully by age 80. That’s our goal.

      After that, living off:

      1. CPP x2
      2. OAS x2
      3. My small DB pension.
      4. Non-reg. dividends.
      5. TFSAs x2 as needed which could be worth quite a bit eventually since money doubles every 9-10 years there at 7-8% even without any new contributions.

      I hope that helps and happy to disucss more anytime.
      Mark

      Reply
      1. John in Stoney Creek · Edit

        Thanks Mark for the detailed response!

        If my wife & I had started our RIF(or RSP) drawdown sooner, we’d be using your exact strategy. Our difference is taking from the TFSA in the current year and replenishing the full amount plus max contribution in the next year.

        Some of the TFSA withdrawals are going to our 3 young adult sons so they can (hopefully) top up their own FHSA and/or TFSA. So, in our eyes, that money is continuing to be highly tax efficient.

        With the cash wedge in place, we will likely increase our annual RIF withdrawals, to re-fund the cash wedge, rather than take from the TFSA.

        Managing our finances is my unpaid retirement side gig 😃

        Reply
        1. LOL, re: “Managing our finances is my unpaid retirement side gig”

          Good stuff.

          You’re wise to funnel any TFSA withdrawals / tax-free money to family while you can, for their FHSA or TFSA. Either account is golden for 20-somethings these days just starting out.

          I appreciate your comments,
          Mark

          Reply
    2. Hey John – fellow reader here – nice to e-meet you. 😉

      You wrote: “…while also creating an opportunity to transfer our entire 2027 RIF withdrawal (the bulk of our 2027 taxable income) directly into our TFSAs with in-kind stock transfers.”

      If that’s your plan, just be aware that the fair market value (FMV) of the shares at the time of the transfer would have to fit entirely within your available TFSA contribution limit. Otherwise, exceeding this limit would trigger a 1% monthly penalty tax on the excess amount.

      I’m not an expert by any means – but that’s my understanding. Mark / others – correct me if my understanding is incorrect.

      Reply
      1. Correct…I haven’t done this yet (RRIF to TFSA) but it’s a two-step dance:

        You can transfer specific investments (securities) directly “in-kind” from your RRIF to a TFSA at fair market value without selling them first, but it is still treated as a taxable withdrawal…then you can contribute for tax-free investing.

        Source:
        https://www.moneysense.ca/columns/ask-a-planner/tax-implications-transferring-rrif-to-tfsa/

        Personally, I would consider selling in RRIF or having cash in RRIF first, then make cash withdrawal, then put cash into TFSA. Easy math for tax reporting and TFSA contribution tracking.

        Cheers,
        Mark

        Reply
      2. John in Stoney Creek · Edit

        Hi MikeyP
        Nice to meet you too!

        Thanks for the tip about the penalties on TFSA over contributions. I’m am aware and ensure I don’t go over.

        There are similar penalties for over contributing to a FHSA. My son learned that the hard way, but caught it quickly, and rectified it. He will be asking CRA for forgiveness on this (hopefully) one and only time over contributing.

        Reply
  4. Hi Mark. Hope you don’t mind if I go off topic a little bit. I’m retiring at the end of the year and have been building up cash positions in HISA and some GIC ladders. The Canadian side is fairly straightforward. However I get a little over 25k in US$ dividends and distributions. Our US$ cash HISA balance is now over 60k. I don’t like buying high in the US market so I recently converted 25k US$ to Canadian and ended up with a little over 35k Canadian. Our retirement plan was originally to spend January to March in a warm state like Arizona. But with the current politics south of the border we are looking at other options. What do you do with your US$ dividends? Convert them or keep them in US$? I know we lose a little in the conversion. We could take the US$ and take them out and put them in our US$ bank account. We know US$ are accepted in most places other than the US where we plan to travel to. What are others doing with their US $ investments ? Thank you Mark for your insights. Cheers.

    Reply
    1. Love the questions, Don.

      I can share what we did pre-retirement.

      A few years ago, we built-up our cash/cash wedge inside our RRSP – largely started thinking about this almost 10-years ago and followed it. 🙂

      https://www.myownadvisor.ca/our-bucket-approach-to-earning-income-in-retirement/

      All Canadian $$ for the most part.

      With the USD $$ side of the RRSP, after selling off all U.S. stocks and ETFs in recent years, we’re left with one Canadian stock that pays dividends in USD $ for USD cashflow. So, what happens for us is that stock pays dividends in USD and that currency builds up. With all DRIPs off thoughout our RRSPs and LIRAs now, I suspect what we’ll do is convert USD $$ to CDN $$ later this year.

      That’s on the registered side.

      On the taxable side, more liquid, we have a USD $$ account and we keep some USD $$ there for travel as needed but we’re not going to the U.S. anytime soon. We do use USD $$ when we travel to Central America for things but most of the transactions we make we put that on a no-fee FX credit card as to avoid any currency conversion charges.

      So, to summarize:

      1. Very little USD $$ currency now as part of our overall portfolio in registered accounts.
      2. Keep some USD $$ currency in taxable account for travel as needed.

      I hope that helps a bit.
      Curious to know if that could work for you and your travel in USD $$?

      Mark

      Reply
      1. Thank you Mark. This is very useful. If I’ve learned one thing about investing it would be information gathering and knowledge are so very important. Cheers Mark.

        Reply
  5. It is all about how much you want to pay your senior care? If you are end your senior care in a private senior house, you probably need millions when you retire

    Reply
  6. Lloyd (66, retired at 55) · Edit

    I believe the important caveat he put on possibly moving out of equities was upon reaching his early 70’s and “seeing that he would have enough” to last his remaining years. Not only do I agree with that position, I also did that, albeit at age 66. My RRIF, RRSP and LIF are now 95% GICs and only a single equity at 5%.

    When I retired at age 55, my 3 registered retirement portfolios had a year end market value of 682K. I took some funds out almost every year since retirement amounting to 271K. This spring, after the last few years of unprecedented growth, these accounts reached in excess of 1.8M. It was obvious that this was an absurd amount given my current age, health status, and existing pension, so I took all the risk out of those accounts. There was no rational reason for me to continue to expose *those* funds to market risk.

    So now those retirement funds are locked in, they will only decrease in total value as the mandatory withdrawals increase annually, and only by the amount that the withdrawal percentage exceeds the interest rate earned. It was easy enough to punch those numbers into a withdrawal calculator to check the numbers.

    I’m NOT saying this is a good move for everyone and YMMV. But it is not a bad move in some scenarios.

    Reply
    1. What was the famous Buffet saying(one of them anyway)… “why risk something I have for something I don’t need.”

      That is a sleep at night portfolio…congrats!

      Reply
    2. Very interesting…I didn’t know you were so high in GICs: re: “My RRIF, RRSP and LIF are now 95% GICs and only a single equity at 5%.”

      At the end of the day, you take on the required risk to meet your goals and nothing more is required. I get that.

      I think I struggle with Duane thinking there are no emergency or healthcare risks in the coming 20-30 years that might undo his modest spending plan. When YouTube makes up more than 50% of your monthly income AND you haven’t factored-in any emergenices like the host Rob rightly pointed out – I think that’s too much risk.

      Maybe he will be more than fine. I have no idea. Seems like too much risk to me.

      You’ve done very well with our overall gains!!

      Reply
      1. The TFSA is for all intents and purposes still 100% equities. The non-reg is around 50/50 but the fixed income in there is quasi-allocated for possible spending items. For example, the A/C and furnace are over 30 years old, some landscaping around the house should be done, and I’m still wembling on a new truck. I’m gonna pass on the interior renos on the house for the next occupant(s) to do.

        Reply
        1. Good stuff on the TFSA…I’m very biased as you know on that since I think it’s the best account for growth.
          We’re 100% equities all the time in our TFSAs.
          Mark

          Reply
          1. I believe we are 100% agreement on the TFSA. It’s such a great product whether growth, income, or combination. It’s also great as a backup quasi-insurance product for spousal survivor issues. OAS and most of CPP will likely disappear “in the event of” so having the roll over to spouse is a huge plus IMO.

            Reply

Post Comment