Then and Now – BlackRock

Then and Now – BlackRock

Hey Everyone,

Welcome to another Then and Now post, a continuation of my series where I revisit some older blogposts and either rip them to shreds (because my thinking has totally changed on such subjects, including key stocks) or I’ll confirm my position on some specific stocks or ETF investments.

You can read about my previous Then and Now posts on certain stocks (the good, and the not-so-good!) during this post. Some DIY stock selection comes with risks. It can also come with large gains too.

Today’s post is/was about my ownership in a significant multinational investment company: BlackRock.

Read on for the history!

Then and Now – BlackRock

Unlike some other stocks in my portfolio, I started buying BlackRock (BLK) in 2016, which was a relatively recent purchase.

Compare that to Enbridge (ENB) which was my very first individual stock – I’ve owned that company for over 15 years now.

Since that ENB purchase, I’ve loaded up on Canadian bank stocks, telco companies and utilities over the years. I’ve also purchased lower-yielding, higher-dividend growers like Waste Connections (WCN) and some U.S. stocks like BlackRock that deliver some appreciation.

I’m glad I did. 

Dividends are great, don’t get me wrong, but growth is good too!

To simplify and diversify my portfolio, I’ve kicked a few of my former favourite U.S. stocks to the curb in favour of a low-cost indexing approach beyond Canada.

Some examples include:

My 10-year+ ownership in Procter & Gamble (PG:US)

Johnson & Johnson (JNJ:US) – my longest running U.S. stock in my portfolio.

And, today’s stock. 

Then – BLK

I started writing about my ownership in BlackRock many years ago.

For those that don’t know, BlackRock (BLK:US) is the world’s largest asset manager but they’ve had up and downs like most stocks do over the years. I was fortunate with this investment selection and holding period.

In 2022 when I posted this original Then and Now article, BlackRock’s stock price was down a bundle just like the broader S&P 500 index was at the same time. 

From 2022 to late-2024, it caught fire, and I held. 

Until recently. 

Then and Now - BlackRock

Source: Google Finance. 

Now – BLK

I started buying BLK stock around $300 USD per share.

I sold all my BLK stock at over $1,000 USD per share in January 2025.

In 2023, I wrote: 

“I own BLK for some stability inside my RRSP that should help me fund future semi-retirement income needs as I slowly drawdown that account.”

Well, those days have come.

In our Financial Independence Update in the summer of 2024, to help prepare for retirement funding, established readers will know I’ve been allocating a higher position to cash/cash equivalents for near-term RRSP withdrawals. 

Financial Independence Update

2026 is likely the start of that retirement spending year.

The sale of all BlackRock stock and stopping all Dividend Reinvestment Plans (DRIPs) has put that retirement spending plan into motion.

Then and Now – BlackRock summary

When it comes to longer-term returns, it was always my hope that BLK would largely keep pace with the broader index, like the S&P 500 returns, and deliver some dividend income I could reinvest or redeploy as I please along the way.

For many years, mission accomplished.

BlackRock served me well to help fund some retirement plans. 

The sale of more U.S. stocks will likely occur in the coming year or so – I am likely to keep just low-cost ETF XAW as my main ETF for long-term growth.

Thanks for reading!

Mark

Check out more selected Then and Now posts and stock ownership decisions below:

I posted my update with TD Bank here.

This was my update about owning Telus. 

Check out my fall 2022 update with Waste Connections (WCN). 

I’ve owned Fortis (FTS) stock for many years, and still do at the time of this post in early 2025. 

I bought Walmart (WMT) stock for many years….do I still own it? Read on!

Do you own BLK, now? Have you ever considered owning it? Did you sell it? Why or why not?

20 Responses to "Then and Now – BlackRock"

  1. Hi Mark,
    My comment is more about that you said you had stopped all your DRIPs a year ahead of retirement. I plan to do that for myself in my portfolio before I retire as well. Do you feel that one year is sufficient time for you to accumulate the cash needed for spending? Is this your plan going forward without ever going back to DRIPs again?

    Reply
    1. Thanks for your questions, Sharon.

      I have stopped DRIPs inside the RRSPs and Taxable accounts we have.
      I keep it “on” for TFSAs and my LIRA.

      I turned off the DRIPs for my RRSPs since I want the cash balance to build up so I can “live off dividends” in early retirement.
      I turned off the DRIPs for our taxable accounts since: 1. I was tired of keeping track of the adjusted cost base and also, 2. we need/want to live off dividends from those taxable accounts starting in 2026.

      I’m not sure I will turn on the DRIPs in those accounts ever again to be honest but those DRIPs have been turned off for just over a year now.

      I hope that helps answer the questions!
      Mark

      Reply
      1. Thank you, Mark, for answering my question and congratulations on reaching your retirement milestone! Very impressive with the dividend achievement!

        I will be doing the same as well when it comes to living off dividends.

        Reply
  2. It was announced in various international media just a few days ago that Blackrock’s Larry Fink was buying assets in the U.K.

    Derek Foster who retired twenty years ago at the age of 34 through his dividend growth investing beat him to it. Derek sold all his U.S. equities and added British stocks to his portfolio somewhere around 2022-2023. Perhaps a little early, but I wish him well with his investments …..and no, Derek’s story didn’t get international attention in the business press.

    Reply
    1. Yes, I saw that!
      https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/blackrock-ceo-buying-undervalued-uk-assets-times-reports-2025-04-24/

      I sold back on January 2025 so not sure about my timing but I made good money when I held it and other than a few minor adjustments here and there – I haven’t changed much for the last six months but wanted to share that with readers.

      I met and had dinner with Derek here in Ottawa a few times many, many, years ago. At that time, I think he had 4 kids. Now 8??

      https://www.myownadvisor.ca/catching-derek-foster-canadas-youngest-retiree/

      Wild. 🙂
      Mark

      Reply
  3. I owned BlackRock for quite a few years but sold it at a profit last year, since I could no longer stomach their ethics (or lack thereof). ESG is a non-starter for me since I want the government to regulate societal issues and for companies to make profits for its shareholders while obeying the laws. There is a lot of “greenwashing” going on in ESG, there are no agreed upon standards and benchmarks. IMHO, companies should serve their shareholders by running their businesses well and not getting involved in social justice issues (i.e. Target, Budweiser) that bring harm to company valuation. Unfortunately, BlackRock has become a far too powerful intrusive agent in the market, and is using its mammoth size to manipulate private companies. I don’t want companies like BlackRock voting the shares they hold within their portfolios on my behalf without any input from me, especially when they force those companies into ESG, causing artificial constraints. Thus, I prefer to own individual company stocks, but not BlackRock or ETF’s. Berkshire is a better choice in my view. I might be leaving money on the table but at least I’m able to sleep at night.

    Reply
    1. That’s a very fair and honest take, Randy. I loathe (and see) the rise of greenwashing – which is not good for many reasons. The ability to sleep at night, based on your choices, is important for all of us.

      Curious as to your holdings now? What individual stocks do you own and why?

      Cheers,
      Mark

      Reply
      1. Hi Mark, thank you for My Own Advisor, I really appreciate you and the valuable service you have provided over these past years! BTW, Paul (July 18) made some excellent points upon which I concur, and I liked your response to him. Thanks for your response to my first post; to answer your questions, Mark, my largest holding is BRK-B. I like it because it has many of the benefits of a managed mutual fund (without the management fees), it is managed by an incredibly competent team, and because it has been consistently profitable. Berkshire’s culture is one that avoids reporting for the sake of it, and Warren Buffett believes ESG reporting falls under that umbrella. I wish all corporations would remember their primary audience is the shareholder, not special interest groups, so they would run the company efficiently and competently, and not have to be “looking over their shoulder” for the next social trend. Social issues [ESG] are the mandate of government, not corporations. Governments make laws and companies follow them. The cost of tracking ESG measures internally, from suppliers, and contractors for production of voluntary annual ESG reports must be astronomical … is that cost rewarded by better outcomes for the shareholder? … [I would be surprised but am willing to be wrong on this]. Mr. Buffett said: “Most ESG requests come not from shareholders, but from third party organizations, and, as an organization, Berkshire is more inclined to respond to shareholder needs.” My 2 major disappointments about the trend toward ESG is there are no agreed-to standards or benchmarks (which leads to an awful lot of greenwashing, for example even some companies that are growing monoculture palm oil plantations in areas where diverse native tropical forests once grew can receive fairly high ESG scores). Also, too many companies are being forced to enrol in ESG programs, not because the majority of their shareholders want it, but because huge institutions like BlackRock and Vanguard, etc. are mandating it. I would feel better if BlackRock, et. al., would seek approval from their shareholders prior to forcing ESG mandates (and other social issues) onto its suite of portfolio investments. I think the original intent for ESG was honourable but it seems we have put the cart before the horse – we need to set achievable and agreed-to industry-wide standards and achievable benchmarks before implementing ESG. Additionally, I hold shares in Costco and Constellation Software Inc. which are not ESG companies, but most of the companies I invest in such as Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc., Hydro One, Canadian Natural Resources, National Bank, RBC, etc., etc. are enrolled in ESG programs. The difference (albeit rather subtle), is I get to have a say as an individual shareholder with each of those. It would be democratic if it were not for the big funds voting huge blocks of their customer’s shares to overwhelm the outcome. If individual shareholders choose to vote affirmative for ESG and that affects share performance they rightly get the benefit or loss. When mutual funds and ETFs force companies to enrol then the shareholders are not being represented. This is a huge topic, difficult to give justice to in a forum like this, and I recognize I am probably in the minority. Thank you, Mark, for providing a platform for discussion. 🙂

        Reply
        1. Thanks for your thoughtful comment, Randy.

          First up, I appreciate your kind words. It’s fun to run the site and engage with others.

          Second, happy to engage in any respectful dialogue here. This forum is built for that.

          Third, kudos on your largest holding. Seems very wise to me. BRK-B is basically a small index fund.

          As for ESG, I believe the framework has a lot of merit but greenwashing is a real thing and increasingly, some companies are doing it well – sadly. I also believe in the spirit of ESG but not for a political or shareholder tool. The market will do what the market will do – weed out poor companies that do not deliver value that are engaged with ESG principles or not IMO.

          This is absolutely a huge topic, fully agree, one that one comment or two on a blogpost can’t possibly cover. ESG or otherwise, I do believe in transparency, saving our planet where we can and being better stewards of our natural resources more and more, and good governance. Whatever we want to call it. 🙂

          I appreciate your detailed and thoughtful comment.
          Mark

          Reply
  4. Hi Mark, personally I am against ESG. I invest for the returns from companies not for them to promote environmental, social, and governance issues. For these items I would rather control my support outside of my investing. I think people can absolutely support environmental causes for example, but this should be up to the individual, it shouldn’t be forced on companies to do. Companies should do what they do best whether that be manufacturing, sales, promotion, research, etc. I’ve actually volunteered my time to go out and clean up parks and plant trees. For diversity, I think companies should hire the best people, they shouldn’t hire someone just to fill a quota. I know if I have to have an operation I would prefer to have the best surgeon available. As it turns out, I actually did have eye surgery and I did have one of the best eye surgeons in Toronto, an Indian woman. She was hired because of her qualifications not to fill a quota and I was very pleased to have her as my eye surgeon.

    Reply
    1. Thanks, Paul. I’m all for hiring the best people, for the necessary role. I do not believe in quotas for the sake of quotoas either but where I’m coming from, including my related work, we need to reconcile the deeds associated with many historical lacks of opportunity…

      I prefer that companies offer individuals, including their employees, opportunities to support the environmental and social causes that are dear to them. So, to your point, it’s not forced on companies to do. Companies should be forced to thrive or fail based on the quality of their goods and services.

      Mark

      Reply
      1. Hi Paul,

        For ESG, search for “blackrock ESG controversy” in google.

        Aladdin mostly provides an application allowing using your telephone to open your garage door instead of a remote.

        Hikvision looks like a provider of surveillance equipment for the Chinese government.

        I don’t understand the link between these two companies and BlackRock.

        Reply
          1. Hi Grant,

            Can you elaborate or at the very least provide a summary of what are your concerns with BlackRock?

            Since I neither own BlackRock nor have them on my acquisition radar currently, I don’t intend to spend time researching them. Please state explicitly what are your concerns.

            No, “Do your own research” doesn’t cut it with us.

            Reply
      2. All good, I replied to Grant as well. Not strictly for vs. against, just curious where folks stand.

        I personally believe ESG / ESG reporting will be more important vs. less moving forward. I’ve thought this way for many years now.

        Reply
  5. HI MARK….I would never invest in BLACKROCK even if you could guaranteed me a 1000% return on my investment
    Because the following: ESG, Aladdin, Hikvision and the list goes on
    They are extremely dangerous to the very fabric of our society as we know it today
    if you can sleep well investing in this ideology good for you

    Reply
    1. Well, most investors own BlackRock via indexed funds, just not directly.

      Related to ESG, are you for or against? Not debating, just curious.

      As per CEO:
      “LARRY FINK: I could see a world in five years where ESG is meshed in everything we do. And I believe that’s where it’s going.”

      Thanks for your comment,
      Mark

      Reply

Post Comment